Issue:
99
Page: 30-32
Medicinal Dose of Water-Based Kava Extract Does Not Impair Driving Ability
by Heather S. Oliff, PhD
HerbalGram.
2013; American Botanical Council
Reviewed: Sarris J, Laporte E,
Scholey A, et al. Does a medicinal
dose of kava impair driving? A randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind
study. Traffic Inj Prev.
2013;14(1):13-17.
It is well known that alcohol and
certain pharmaceutical and recreational drugs can impair driving and increase
the risk of accidents. Some medical researchers have expressed concerns that
kava (Piper methysticum, Piperaceae)
root and its preparations have the potential to cause inebriation similar to
that caused by psychotropic substances such as alcohol and benzodiazepines (a
class of pharmaceutical anti-anxiety drugs, which includes the well-known drug
Valium®). Therefore, it is possible that kava may impair the motor
skills and cognitive abilities required for safe driving. For this reason, the
German Commission E, in its therapeutic monograph on kava published in 1990,
included a precaution with respect to driving an automobile or operating heaving
machinery while under the influence of kava.1*
The purpose of this three-arm,
randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind, crossover trial was to evaluate
the acute effects of kava on driving performance. This study was part of the
Kava Anxiety-Lowering Medication (KALM) Project, conducted by the Brain and
Psychological Sciences Research Centre at Swinburne University of Technology in
Melbourne, Australia. Men and women (n=22; aged 16-65 years) with
mild-to-moderate anxiety were recruited via advertising media distributed in
Hawthorn, Victoria, Australia. Patients were excluded for the following
criteria: current use of antidepressants, mood stabilizers, antipsychotics,
opioids, analgesics, or cannabis; substance abuse or dependency disorder in the
previous six months, including alcohol abuse/dependency; previous adverse
reaction to kava or benzodiazepines; regular use of kava or benzodiazepines in
the previous 12 months; more than one occasion of benzodiazepine or kava use
each week over the past month; pregnancy, trying to conceive, or those who
could be pregnant; regular smokers (more than one cigarette a week); and those
with abnormal liver function.
Participants were subjected to a
10-minute practice session on a driving simulator. They then received either
three kava tablets containing a combined total of 180 mg of kavalactones, 30 mg
of oxazepam (a benzodiazepine), or placebo. All treatments looked identical.
The kava tablets (MediHerb Kava, Integria Healthcare Pty Ltd; Warwick,
Australia) were standardized to contain 60 mg of kavalactones per tablet. The
kava preparation was manufactured using a water-extracted precipitate of the
peeled rootstock from a Vanuatu noble cultivar. An independent assay using
high-performance liquid chromatographic analysis revealed higher concentrations
of the kavalactones dihydrokawain, kawain, and dihydromethysticin; moderate
levels of methysticin and yangonin; and lower levels of desmethoxyyangonin. The
alkaloid pipermethystine was not present.
Following treatment administration,
the patients relaxed for 90 minutes until their blood serum had appropriate
levels of kava constituent. They then began a 15-minute computerized driving
simulator program, followed by a visual analog assessment. One week later,
patients were crossed over to another treatment. This routine was repeated a
total of three times, once for each treatment.
Oxazepam produced a significantly
slower braking reaction time than placebo (P=0.002) and kava (P=0.003).
Concentration lapses were significantly fewer with kava than with oxazepam
(P=0.033). An equal number of participants in each treatment group crashed.
Results were not modified by the covariates of driving experience, driving
status, or treatment order. Oxazepam-treated patients reported that they were
significantly less alert than when exposed to the other treatments. All
patients were more fatigued after driving, irrespective of the treatment.
According to the authors, this is
the first study to evaluate the acute effects of a medicinal dose of kava on
driving performance and safety compared to a benzodiazepine. The authors
concluded that at medicinal doses, kava does not alter driving in the same way
as benzodiazepines. Apart from its small sample size, this study had several
limitations. Blood levels of oxazepam peak at two-to-three hours, and the
driving analysis occurred after 90 minutes; therefore, oxazepam may have
produced a more profound effect if evaluated later. The patients were not
screened for medical conditions that could have altered driving vigilance, and
the simulator did not exactly mimic real driving conditions. Also, the
participants had mild-to-moderate anxiety, so the data may not be extrapolated
to the general population.
This study gives important insight
into the effects of a medicinal dose of kava on a population that would use it
(i.e., patients with anxiety).
However, when people use kava for recreational purposes, they consume much
higher doses. Similar to alcohol, as the dose of kava increases, the ability to
safely operate a vehicle may diminish. This study should be replicated with a
recreational dose of kava.
—Heather S. Oliff, PhD
* The German Commission E monograph
notes under Duration of Administration: “Even when administered within its
prescribed dosages, this herb may adversely affect motor reflexes and judgment
for driving and/or operating heavy machinery.”
Reference
1. Blumenthal
M, Busse WR, Goldberg A, Gruenwald J, Hall T, et al. The Complete German
Commission E Monogaphs: Therapeutic Guide to Herbal Medicines. Austin,
Texas: American Botanical Council; Boston, MA: Integrative Medicine
Communications, 1998.
|