PDF
(Download)
|
- Chamomile (Matricaria chamomilla syn. M. recutita, Asteraceae)
- Skin Damage
|
Date:
02-28-2018 | HC# 081712-587
|
Re: A Review of Chamomile Preparations Used for Treating Skin Damage
Ferreira
EB, Vasques CI, Jesus CAC, Reis PED. Topical effects of Chamomilla recutita in skin damage: a literature review. Pharmacologyonline. 2015;3:123-130.
Chamomile
(Matricaria recutita syn. M. chamomilla, Asteraceae) flowers are a
well-known medicinal herb that have been used to treat various skin conditions.
Numerous studies have provided evidence that chamomile may be effective at
treating different types of skin disorders due to its antioxidant,
anti-inflammatory, and anti-allergic properties. The aim of this review was to
assess the literature and evaluate the use of chamomile for preventing and/or
treating skin damage.
A
literature search was conducted using Cochrane Library, PubMed, Latin American
and Caribbean Health Sciences Literature (LILACS), Cumulative Index to Nursing
and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), and Web of Science databases.
Publications in Portuguese, English, Spanish, and German languages were
included. There were no limitations on publication dates, but case studies,
preclinical studies, reviews, and letters to the editor were excluded from the
study. Search words and terms included Matricaria, chamomile, Chamomilla recutita, and variations of these
names, and skin care or skin disease, among others. There were two reviewers
that selected the articles independently, and a third reviewer intervened if
there were any disagreements.
Out
of the 392 publications that were eligible for the review, 17 studies were
selected, and 11 were used for qualitative synthesis for this review. The included
studies assessed the topical effects of chamomile for different skin
conditions, including the following: ultraviolet (UV)-induced erythema,
pityriasis alba, lesions similar to eczema, peristomal lesions, contact
dermatitis, phlebitis, atopic eczema, erythema induced by removal of adhesive
tape, radiodermatitis, induced contact dermatitis, wound, and eczema. There
were six studies in English, four in German, and one in Portuguese.
The
chamomile formulations used included aqueous and alcohol extracts, infusions,
creams, and an ointment (2% chamomile extract with the terpene compounds
α-bisabolol and chamazulene; Kamillosan®; Menarini; Florence,
Italy). In six of the studies, chamomile treatments showed superior therapeutic
effects compared to corticosteroids. Studies with Kamillosan, consisting of 2%
chamomile flower extract, delayed the onset of erythema and moist desquamation
resulting from radiotherapy, compared to another reference ointment. Kamillosan
cream also was found to be more effective than corticosteroids, but similar to
the placebo for the treatment of eczema. In another study, Kamillosan cream was
found to be as effective for eczema treatment as the corticosteroid
hydrocortisone (0.25%), but more effective than the corticosteroids fluocortin
(0.75%) and bufexamac. Finally, Kamillosan ointment was shown to be superior to
a reference product for its soothing effects on the skin of patients with
contact dermatitis.
Peristomal
lesions also healed faster in the group using an aqueous chamomile extract
compared to those using hydrocortisone treatment. A compress infused with 2.5%
chamomile flower extract was found to be the most effective in a dose-response
study that evaluated regression of vein inflammation. A chamomile extract was
also found to reduce wound area more effectively than a placebo treatment. When
evaluating different formulations, it was found that a chamomile extract was
more effective in a liposomal cream preparation than a non-liposomal cream
preparation.
On
the other hand, a cream-based treatment with chamomile alcohol extracts was
found to be no different than the placebo treatments for pityriasis alba and other
eczema-like conditions. A study found that a (20 mg/g) chamomile-based cream
had less anti-inflammatory activity in patients with UV-induced erythema
compared with a 1% hydrocortisone cream. A study comparing six different plant
extracts also found that corticosteroids were more effective than a 1%
chamomile extract.
This
review demonstrated the support from several studies that chamomile
preparations can be more effective than corticosteroids for treating skin
damage. In particular, it appears concentrations around 2-2.5% were the most effective.
Although these results are promising, the authors did not clarify whether or
not different chamomile species were included in the studies. Other species, such as Chamaemelum spp., have an increased risk of adverse reactions when
used topically. There also is an increased risk of allergic cross-reactions in
individuals with a preexisting sensitization to sesquiterpene lactones of the
Asteraceae family. Future
trials should assess different doses of chamomile extracts, confirm the plant
species, assess bioactive compound concentrations/profiles/mechanisms of
action, and evaluate the effects the chamomile preparations have on different
skin conditions.
—Laura M. Bystrom, PhD
|